Our Classic Butter caramel is a best-selling favorite. Slow-cooked, hand-poured, and extra soft, this artisanal classic is sweet, milky, and mellow. Like butter itself, each bite makes any moment more enjoyable. And, they are naturally gluten-free!
Receive exclusive perks that can be used across our entire family of stores (a total of 8 right now)!
Now only $9.95 per year!
Overall rating: 4.893652 / 5 from 2426 reviews.
Classic Butter caramel is a best-selling favorite known for its slow-cooked, hand-poured, and extra soft texture. Customers love its sweet, milky, and mellow flavor, excellent quality, and great packaging. It is also a popular gift choice and offers fast shipping.
Review topics: ["size","flavor","quality","feelings","gift","shipping","price","work","packaging","variety","texture","order","treat","box","goodness","service","favorite","consistency","batch","caramels","bite","husband","vanilla","carmels","assortment","tooth","delight","butter","chocolate","price point"].
"All of the flavors I have tried are wonderful. These, however, are my favorites. They are easy to eat, don’t stick to your teeth and are so very good. They are soft and full of creamy caramel taste. No frills needed for this perfect caramel."
"Okayyyy…lemme tell you how good these are. They are buttery but only enhances the caramel. This is as close to normal caramel flavor, but with a melt in your mouth chewiness that’s not sticky, and you will have a hard time finding a more perfect caramel than these!"
"Makes a great gift for the sister who craves the best candies! A please consider would be to mark the wrappers for each flavor since some of the differences are subtle…."
"These caramels exceeded our expectations. Everything from the ease of order, variety from which to choose, packaging, flavors, delivery, and most importantly they were so delicious. The price was exceptional for th value. Will definitely purchase again. We packaged them in smaller bags for party favors for my daughter’s baby shower."
"Once you try these caramels, you will never eat another brand. The are so smooth and flavorful. Everyone I have sent them to love them."
"These are the best tasting caramels I have ever had, and I am in my 70's"
"I loved it. I gave part of them away, additional to the gifts I gave out. Everyone loved them. They melt in your mouth"
"Outstanding!. Melt in your mouth full of flavor. Have trouble stopping eating them. Yum!"
"Tasted the many flavors in the Sampler and most got high grades."
"My favorite and also to give for any occasion"
Your cart is currently empty
Attention: If you're looking for immediate delivery options, continue to checkout. Your delivery may arrive up to 2 business days earlier than date selected.
