Smooth, rich peanut butter and sweet caramel softness in one bite. This sweet and salty balance reminds us of simple joys—peanut butter sandwiches, snacking by the spoonful, and one of the most timeless comfort foods we know. And, they are naturally gluten-free!
Receive exclusive perks that can be used across our entire family of stores (a total of 8 right now)!
Now only $9.95 per year!
Overall rating: 4.580858 / 5 from 303 reviews.
Creamy Peanut Butter offers a delightful combination of smooth, rich peanut butter and sweet caramel, praised for its great flavor and satisfying order experience. Customers find it perfect as a gift and are likely to reorder.
Review topics: ["flavor","shipping","price","order","packaging","gift","texture","caramels","chocolate","treat","favorite","butter","carmels","candy","containers","omg","soo","chewy"].
"The peanut butter caramels have a nice nutty flavor. They are soft and not super sticky."
"My first time purchasing from your company and they were all fantastic!!"
"Could be a lil peanut buttery in flavor, but delicious anyway."
"EXCELLENT!"
"Delicious!!!!!"
"I've had them before and ordered them tor a present to a dear friend, they loved yhem,!"
"I never would’ve guessed that this was supposed to be peanut butter flavored. It seems like just a plain caramel. I bought this specifically for a friend who loves peanut butter. I am disappointed and will not be giving it to her unless I roll each caramel flat, spread a little Jiff on it and top it with another rolled caramel slab. I figure that I can cut a stack into little chunks and hand roll them into REAL peanut butter flavored caramels. I ordinarily LOVE your caramels, but these are a BIG disappointment."
"It was soft like the normal sea salt vanilla caramel. However, this didn't taste like peanut butter at all. It had a more burnt taste to it than anything. I love PB products and was quite disappointed with this."
"Better than I thought they would be. They are so tasty and soft. My new favorite flavor."
"Liked the peanut butter carmel - it's very good."
Your cart is currently empty
Attention: If you're looking for immediate delivery options, continue to checkout. Your delivery may arrive up to 2 business days earlier than date selected.
