Skip to content

Arrives Fast & Fresh

40+ Flavors to Choose From

About Us Help
Skip to product information
  • Sugar Cookie
  • Sugar Cookie
  • Sugar Cookie
  • Sugar Cookie
  • Sugar Cookie
  • Sugar Cookie
  • Sugar Cookie
177 Reviews

Sugar Cookie

$18.00
Sugar Cookie
New product
$18.00
Add a personal gift note in checkout Hold delivery for a future date at checkout Arrives fast & fresh

Warm, buttery, vanilla-sweet goodness. Each bite into a Sugar Cookie caramel makes for a melt-in-your mouth, decadent moment. Slow-cooked, hand poured, and irresistible. And, they are naturally gluten-free!

Caramel (Corn Syrup, Sweetened Condensed Milk (Milk, Sugar), Cream (Milk, Carrageenan, Mono And Diglycerices) Sugar, Brown Sugar (Sugar, Invert Sugar, Molasses) Butter (Cream, Salt) Invert Sugar, Salt, Natural And Artificial Flavorings, Soy Lecithin.

Contains Bioengineered Food Ingredient. Allergens: Contains Milk, Soy. Produced on equipment that produces items that contain wheat, peanuts, tree nuts.

Recommended Products

Customer Love

WENDY
@WENDY
MARCUS
@MARCUS
MATT
@MATT
JESSICA
@JESSICA
ALEX
@ALEX
KRISTEN
@KRISTEN
ANDREW
@ANDREW

Join The G.O.A.T. Club

Receive exclusive perks that can be used across our entire family of stores (a total of 8 right now)!

Now only $9.95 per year!

Free Shipping On Every Order
Members-Only Monthly Deals
Early Access To New Product Releases
First Dibs On New Brands We Launch

Overall rating: 4.8644066 / 5 from 177 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Sugar Cookie caramels are praised for their fantastic flavor and high likelihood of repeat orders. However, some customers find the texture to be grainy.

Summary topics

  • Flavor (38%): Many customers brought up that the flavor of the caramels was fantastic and they loved it.
  • Texture (6%): Customers have mixed opinions about the texture, with some finding it grainy and not silky smooth.
  • Repeat Order (7%): It was highlighted by customers that they would definitely order again and they would try different flavors as well.

Review topics: [flavor, price, texture, order, smell, gift, price point, caramels, carmels, cookies, butter, memories, sweets, ordering, christmas, hit].

Review highlights

  • "The sugar cookie and the classic butter were both excellent tasting Caramels." — Stephen T.
  • "Great taste and texture" — Deidra W.
  • "Nice flavor and texture" — Shelia R.

Reviews

Great flavor.

"Great flavor."

— Brian S. (5/5)

…

"…"

— Michael C. (4/5)

Taste just like the cookie

"Taste just like the cookie"

— Cindy P. (5/5)

Awesome Flavor

"Awesome Flavor"

— Carolyn P. (5/5)

EXCELLENT

"I Loved the Sugar Cookie Carmel Too"

— Cathy W. (5/5)

great

"Love it"

— Michael S. (5/5)

I haven’t tried one that

"I haven’t tried one that I didn’t like"

— Tami M. (5/5)

Taste like a sweeter classic

"Taste like a sweeter classic butter"

— Charlene K. (3/5)

This is another delicious alternative

"This is another delicious alternative to the original caramel. If you like sugar cookies, this is a must have choice."

— RONALD P. (5/5)

I still haven’t received the

"I still haven’t received the sure cookies I ordered and paid for"

— Cindi H. (2/5)

Q&A

Add $99.00 more to unlock FREE SHIPPING

Your Cart

Your cart is currently empty

Personalization note

Schedule Delivery

Attention: If you're looking for immediate delivery options, continue to checkout. Your delivery may arrive up to 2 business days earlier than date selected.